Why stalin and not trotsky was able to succeed lenin

Why stalin emerged as the sole leader of the ussr and not trotsky trotsky was a leading bolshevik and played a pivotal role in the revolution, persuading lenin to delay the revolution until the bolshevik’s had a much stronger place in the country. Stalin was not the natural successor of vladimir lenin, but he was able to use his position within the soviet communist party to become the undisputed leader of the soviet union stalin’s early life joseph stalin, the future leader of the soviet union, often referred to as the ‘red tsar', was born on 18 december 1878 to a georgian cobbler. In addition, they didn’t see stalin as much of a threat and thought they could use him to help defeat trotsky, who was seen as very good in lenin’s testament zinoviev, kamenev and stalin were at the height of the race at the moment. After lenin's death in '24, bukharin (nep), trotsky (permanent revolution), and stalin (socialism in one country) all were looking to fill lenin's place trotsky, during lenin's funeral, was sick and out of the town.

why stalin and not trotsky was able to succeed lenin Assess the reasons why stalin was able to rise to power in russia after the death of lenin  stalins rise to power struggle with trotsky:  would success lenin as party leader however joseph stalin managed to become leader of russia because he was better.

Lenin send some message to party leaders where he criticize everyone and told that neither stalin nor trotsky is good fit for the leader also there was some bad statements about other popular party leaders. Granted, trotsky would have prepared the red army better for war than stalin did with his purges, but it was stalin's brutality and efficiency that led the red army being able to defeat the wehrmacht. Why stalin and not trotsky was able to succeed lenin the first reason why stalin and not trotsky was able to succeed lenin was because stalin had an important position of general secretary he used his position as secretary to put his supporters on the central committee of the party and dismissed trotsky’s.

Stalin did not succeed in gaining power over lenin lenin remained in power until he suffered a series of three strokes beginning in 1922 which curtailed his activity and ultimately caused his. Lenin designated five of his closest companions as chosen to succeed him: trotsky, zinoviev, kamenev, bukharin and pyatakov five years later stalin had ousted all of them from the control of affairs, and was waiting to exterminate them. Vladimir lenin himself had wanted trotsky to become his successor, mostly because he feared that joseph stalin had an evil soul after lenin's death, it was a face-off between leon trotsky & stalin. - why stalin emerged as the sole leader of the ussr and not trotsky trotsky was a leading bolshevik and played a pivotal role in the revolution, persuading lenin to delay the revolution until the bolshevik’s had a much stronger place in the country. Foreword the document later known as lenin’s testament was, as trotsky says in his biography of stalin, “lenin’s last advice on how to organize the party leadership”a year before his death lenin, with his unerring political insight, saw in stalin’s policies the beginnings of what lenin himself called “bureaucratism not only in the soviet institutions but also in the party.

'the truth is that trotsky refrained from attacking stalin because he felt after lenin’s death, a power struggle ensued that resulted in a shift from collective leadership in the soviet union to josef stalin emerging and establishing his position as the individual leader of the state. Trotsky failed to attend the funeral after stalin lied to him over the date, this was a major blow to trotsky’s reputation as it was assumed he must not have cared about lenin stalin was able to succeed the power struggle through the flaws of his biggest opposition, trotsky. Stalin's rise to power the struggle to succeed lenin originated not with his death in 1924 but from 1922 when he suffered the first if a succession of strokes by 1929, josef stalin had emerged as the sole leader of the communist party. Why stalin was able to win the power struggle with trotsky the bolsheviks, the ruling party of the soviet union, was lead by the lenin when lenin died in january of 1924, he left behind no clear successor, and vague indications of his intended plans for the bolshevik party. Stalin vs trotsky this is a reprint especially lenin b trotsky trotsky, like stalin, was born in 1879 his real name was lev davidovich bronstein his father was a well-to-do jewish farmer in the ukrainian province of kherson actually stalin, as general secretary, was able to bolster his own influence by guiding the party machinery.

Stalin stands out because not only was he able to build a massive amount of military power, he managed to stay in power for three decades, much longer than any comparable dictator there was no succession struggle to succeed lenin as i showed in the first volume because stalin was all ready in power from the spring of 1922, when lenin. Well, the word succeed in this case does not mean to be successful, in this instance it means to follow, so, yes, stalin followed, or succeeded lenin as the premier of the soviet union, although rykov and molotov were in between them (see link, below. You don't kill either because it's not that simplistic the october revolution barring bolshevik agitation, happen when lenin was forced to the wilderness and trotsky in jail if i remember correctly, the only reason the october revolution happened is because the kornilov affair saw kerensky free the bolsheviks and give them weapons. I think stalin succeed lenin by doing all of these like unfair things and the death of lenin really helped a lot also, it’s interesting because stalin was following lenin’s footsteps, but taking it to another level of extreme. Lenin died of a stroke, but was ill for some time, not able to give instructions as to who should succeed him there were troubles within the party without a clear leader, and party members began to accuse each other of putting forward ideas that went against the communist ideals.

Zinoviev and lev kamenev became part of the troika (triumvirate) formed by stalin to ensure that trotsky, publicly the number-two man in the country and lenin's heir presumptive, [citation needed] would not succeed lenin. The statement “stalin won because trotsky lacked a power base” does not explain the actual reasons as to why trotsky did not succeed lenin as the leader of the soviet state trotsky had the most powerful power base in russia at the time which was that he had control of the red army. In my opinion he was just very bad at social situations and possibly verged on autism, which is why he did not go to the funeral to mourn, did not even try to build a strong power base within the bolsheviks and didn't use lenin's name as a cult of personality in order to gain support like stalin did. Joseph stalin was the general secretary of the communist party of the soviet union's central committee from 1922 until his death in 1953 in the years following the death of vladimir lenin in 1924, stalin rose to become the leader of the soviet union after growing up in georgia, stalin conducted discreet activities for the bolshevik party for twelve years before the russian revolution of 1917.

  • Published: mon, 5 dec 2016 in 1922, when vladimir lenin became incapacitated, there was a clear need of a successor for the soviet union as he was slowly dying, a power struggle emerged between leon trotsky, and joseph stalin.
  • Nick surry hiliary 2013: fs30 why did stalin win the struggle for the lenin succession the struggle for the lenin succession started long before the death of the leader of the bolshevik party in january 1924 in reality, the process had begun after lenin was ‘permanently removed from the.
  • The second reason why stalin and not trotsky was able to succeed lenin was that many communists felt that stalin was more loyal to the party whilst trotsky was seen as arrogant trotsky had joined the bolsheviks very late in 1917 and was a member of the mensheviks, whereas stalin was there from a very long time.

Of all the times stalin manipulated trotsky, like the incident at lenin’s funeral, not once did trotsky speak out and state what stalin had been doing this meant that no body really knew what stalin was like behind the scenes.

why stalin and not trotsky was able to succeed lenin Assess the reasons why stalin was able to rise to power in russia after the death of lenin  stalins rise to power struggle with trotsky:  would success lenin as party leader however joseph stalin managed to become leader of russia because he was better. why stalin and not trotsky was able to succeed lenin Assess the reasons why stalin was able to rise to power in russia after the death of lenin  stalins rise to power struggle with trotsky:  would success lenin as party leader however joseph stalin managed to become leader of russia because he was better.
Why stalin and not trotsky was able to succeed lenin
Rated 5/5 based on 44 review

2018.